Jesper Berg
- Acceptable QLC performance
- Affordable
- Low endurance ratings
As of early 2019, the Crucial P1 is one of few SSDs that uses QLC, or quad-level cell, NAND Flash memory. This makes it an entry-level alternative among other drives using the PCI Express/NVMe interface/protocol. Performance and endurance ratings are lower than average in the segment, but in general, the P1 will still be faster than SATA SSDs.
Memory Type, Controller and Cache
Quad-level cell NAND has to work with four bits per cell, which negatively affects durability and performance compared to triple-level cell (TLC) and multi-level cell (MLC). There are however also advantages to an increased memory cell density, most notably more efficient manufacturing and in turn, lower prices.
The Crucial P1 does not use a proprietary controller. Instead, Micron has opted for an SM2263 from Silicon Motion. This is a 4-channel controller intended for entry-level NVMe SSDs. Contrary to the naming, the SM2263 will be slower than the 8-channel SM2262 controller which is used in several higher-end SSDs.
To compensate for the QLC memory chips’ lower performance, particularly in the write area, the Crucial P1 uses a single-level cell or SLC-type cache to maintain a write performance that exceeds SATA-level speeds. When the SLC cache is exhausted, performance will drop well below most mainstream 2.5″ SATA SSDs.
The amount of NAND used in SLC mode is allocated dynamically. All capacities of the Crucial P1 also include a DRAM DDR3 (512GB and 1TB capacities) or DDR4 (2TB capacity) cache buffer.
Performance
As with all other SSDs, the Crucial P1’s performance increases with the drive’s capacity up to a certain point, meaning that the 2TB capacity is faster than the 1TB, which in turn is faster than the 512GB model.
| Crucial P1 SSD Specifications | 500 GB | 1 TB | 2 TB |
|---|---|---|---|
| Form Factor | M.2 2280 (single-sided) | M.2 2280 (single-sided) | M.2 2280 (double-sided) |
| Interface | NVMe 1.3 PCIe 3.0 x4 | NVMe 1.3 PCIe 3.0 x4 | NVMe 1.3 PCIe 3.0 x4 |
| Controller | Silicon Motion SM2263 | Silicon Motion SM2263 | Silicon Motion SM2263 |
| NAND Flash | Micron 64-layer 3D QLC NAND | Micron 64-layer 3D QLC NAND | Micron 64-layer 3D QLC NAND |
| DRAM | 512MB DDR3 | 1GB DDR3 | 2GB DDR4 |
| Sequential Read | 1900 MB/s | 2000 MB/s | 2000 MB/s |
| Sequential Write | 950 MB/s | 1700 MB/s | 1750 MB/s |
| Random Read | 90K IOPS | 170K IOPS | 250K IOPS |
| Random Write | 220K IOPS | 240K IOPS | 250K IOPS |
| SLC Write Cache (dynamic) | 5GB-50GB | 12GB-100GB | 24GB-200GB |
| Endurance rating (terabytes written) | 100 TB | 200 TB | 400 TB |
Due to the comparatively low-end nature of QLC memory, no such SSD is among the segment’s top performers.
Power Consumption (Laptop Battery Life)
According to the official numbers, the Crucial P1’s maximum power draw is 8W (controller: 9W). While idle, and on average, it should be much less. TweakTown has performed a practical battery life test with P1 and found it to be slightly better than the popular Samsung 970 EVO, but not as efficient as the Intel 760p.
Warranty and Endurance Rating
Micron offers an industry-standard 5-year warranty with the Crucial P1. However, due to the QLC memory chips, endurance ratings are comparatively (very) low at:
- 512 GB: 100 TBW
- 1 TB: 200 TBW
- 2 TB: 400 TBW
Measured as drive writes per day (DWPD), these numbers equal about 0.1 DWPD for the warranty duration.
Reviews
For performance, the drive did well when considering the target audience and comparing it to another QLC product in the same segment.
The 500GB Crucial P1 isn’t the perfect SSD for all users, but it’s not too far off from being a very good drive for many.
Specification: Crucial P1 NVMe QLC SSD
|
